@RoninGrey To be fair, the show would be bad regardless of who's cast as supergirl. I mean, why would anyone want to watch a show about a woman who's stronger than men and behaves like one?
But I don't even get the appeal of superhero stories for the most part. I'm baffled so many people watch that stuff.
@RoninGrey I get it, I enjoyed the original Spiderman movie trilogy when I was a kid and the more recent Joker film, as an adult. Still, I find the super-hero theme itself unappealing, always did. I dislike the whole "protecting the weak and fighting petty crime is your responsibility" that seems to be the foundation of the genre.
And that Marvel stuff gives me the shivers. The quirky humor, the safe jokes, the lame stories and of course, the subliminal Disney agenda... blegh
@Based_Accelerationist But as a reader, I did like Supergirl as a character, back in the day.
The thing about comics is that there are runs where a certain writer / artist combo just knocks it out of the park for a year or two, making fantastic work, but then the same character gets handed to another team and the stories and art could suck ass for 20 years so you're just SOL.
@RoninGrey I was never into reading superhero comic books, so I wouldn't know, but that makes sense.
Still, even if some of the stories were great, I just don't see myself getting over the fact I dislike Superman (or supergirl) as a concept.
Closest thing to a superman show I'll watch, is One Punch Man, but that's basically a mockery of the superhero genre.
@Based_Accelerationist I liked the last Batman because it was basically a noir film. I like it when the genre isn't "superhero" but something else, in a world with heroes. I like fantasy / dark fantasy, detective / mystery films, action films, family-friendly films, philosophical films, thrillers, period pieces, war films, etc. So if a superhero movie does THAT well, I enjoy it. I really liked Watchmen, for example, and Captain America: First Avenger, but not because of "superheroes."