Maybe you people can understand my problem with RDR2, context, in RDR1 John Marston is an Ex outlaw, now a husband and a father, he is working with the law by force but still wants to do the right thing, the game has a honor system, John does the good thing Honor gain, bad Honor lost simple.

RDR2 you play as Arthur Morgan, an Outlaw in the same game John was in, you know criminal, yet the game kept the honor system, YOUR A CRIMINAL!!! GTA IN THE OLD WEST!! the majority of thing you do is bad!!!